On January 28, 2022, a customer uses a credit card to pay for an item at a retail store in New York City.
Robert Nickelsburg Getty Images
Banks that issue credit cards used by millions of consumers have raised interest rates and introduced new fees over the past year in response to impending regulations, which most professionals now I believe it will never come into effect.
Synchrony and Bread Financial, which specializes in issuing branded cards for companies such as Verizon and J.C. Penney, are following the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s announcement of rules that will significantly reduce the late fees the industry can charge. , said the measure was necessary.
“Those are the two banks that have been the most vocal about this because they’re going to be the most affected,” said Sanjay Saklani, a KBW analyst covering the card industry. “But the consensus right now is that this rule is not going to happen.”
As a result, proposed regulations intended to save consumers money are actually increasing costs for some.
On Nov. 22, CNBC reported that interest rates on broad-based retail cards have skyrocketed over the past year, reaching 35.99%. Synchrony and Bread have increased the annual percentage rate (APR) of their portfolios by an average of 3 to 5 percentage points, Saklani said.
In addition, customers of both banks were notified that the new monthly fee to receive paper statements would be $2.99, up from $1.99.
Arrow pointing outside zoom in icon
Synchrony Bank customers received notice of a new monthly fee for receiving paper statements as part of the industry’s response to a CFPB rule capping late fees.
Source: Synchrony
Bread, which issues cards for retailers such as Big Lots and Victoria’s Secret, began raising rates on some cards in late 2023 “in anticipation” of the CFPB’s rules, said Bread CFO Perry. Bieberman told analysts in October.
“We implemented a number of changes that are in the marketplace, including increased APRs and paper statement fees,” Beberman said at the time.
There’s some pain, but nothing to gain.
According to the CFPB, the credit card industry profits by imposing high penalties on borrowers with low credit scores.
In March, the agency introduced a rule capping late fees at $8 per transaction, down from an average of about $32. Regulators said the rule would save consumers $10 billion a year.
But banks and their industry associations argue that late fees are necessary as a deterrent to defaults and that capping them at $8 per transaction will shift costs to banks that pay their bills on time. are.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which calls itself the world’s largest industry group, sued the CFPB in March to block the rule, saying it exceeded its authority. In May, just days before the rule took effect, a federal judge granted the industry’s request to halt enforcement.
While the rule is currently being challenged in court, cardholders are already dealing with higher borrowing costs and fees resulting from the rule.
The impact on consumers will increase in the coming months as consumers accumulate new debt to fund their holiday spending, as higher APRs result in more new loans rather than older debt. Become. Americans borrowed a record $1.17 trillion in credit card loans, an 8.1% increase from a year ago, according to the New York Fed.
“Due to changing regulatory conditions, we have adjusted our interest rates and fees so that we can continue to provide safe and convenient credit to our customers,” a spokesperson for Stamford, Conn.-based Synchrony said in a statement.
Customers can avoid interest and fees by paying off their balances in full and opting out of paper statements, a spokesperson said.
Citigroup, Barclays
Higher borrowing costs will have a big impact on consumers with lower credit scores, who are more likely to hold store cards issued by Synchrony and Bread.
Customers with poor credit scores are considered too risky to take advantage of popular loyalty cards from issuers like JPMorgan Chase and American Express, so they’re more likely to turn to co-branded cards as an alternative. .
Analysts say that’s why Synchrony and Bread were keen to reduce the blow to their operations by raising rates and introducing fees. The concern was that if the late payment penalty was lowered to $8, more customers would simply default on their loans, making the business less profitable.
However, other major banks are raising interest rates as well.
The Banana Republic and Athleta cards issued by Barclays each saw their APRs increase by 5 points over the past year. The annual interest rate on Citigroup’s Home Depot card increased by 3 points, and the annual interest rate on the bank’s Myer card increased by 4 points.
Representatives for Citigroup and Barclays declined to comment.
Capital One had warned earlier this year that it would take steps to offset the blow from the CFPB rule, but said it chose to hold back on certain unspecified investments instead of changing customer prices. The bank is in the process of acquiring rival card issuer Discover Financial.
Even before it went into effect in May, the fate of the CFPB rule was considered uncertain. That’s because the lawsuit challenging the rule was filed in a forum widely seen as favorable to companies seeking to roll back federal regulations.
But policy experts say the next CFPB chief is unlikely to continue those efforts following the election victory of Donald Trump, who has pushed for widespread deregulation across the industry. .
When asked if they would reverse the APR and fee increases once the CFPB rule goes away, Synchrony’s managers did not change their stance. CFO Brian Wenzel told analysts in October that the bank needed to proceed as if it were happening.
“People use the word ‘rollback,'” Wenzel said. “As a company, we never thought about it in real time.”
—CNBC’s Gabriel Fonrouge contributed to this report.
