Backstreet Boys’ ‘Tell Me Why’ understands retention
Even millennials who can’t remember where they put their keys can still perfectly choreograph “Bye Bye Bye” somewhere. to be honest? It should humble us all in our learning and development.
Because if learners remember the following:
Every Word of ‘I Want It That Way’ Who Was the ‘Mystery Member’? The Complete Plot of the 1999 Music Video
…But I can’t remember the compliance training from last quarter…
A discussion may be necessary. Show your respect. But still a conversation.
The truth is, memorable learning doesn’t just happen. Neither were boy bands. From New Kids on the Block to the Backstreet Boys, *NSYNC, One Direction, BTS, and every emotionally destructive heartthrob in between, these groups are designed to stick in our minds.
And surprisingly? The same psychological principles that made boy bands unforgettable are also the exact principles that make workouts memorable. So let’s talk about the science of “training to stick” through a very serious academic lens of frosted tips and coordinating dance numbers.
Why most trainings are forgotten
Let’s start with an inconvenient truth. Many workplace trainings are designed for completion, not retention.
We focus on:
It covers information. Check the box. Continue reading the slides. Completion tracking.
And when the learner holds about three pieces of information and one stock photo of a person wearing a headset, we act surprised. But memory doesn’t work like a filing cabinet. Once the brain decides that this is important, the learning sticks.
Research on learning retention consistently shows that emotion, repetition, context, and active participation all play key roles in long-term memory. And the brain tends to prioritize:
Emotional Repetitive Unique Social Story-driven Personally Meaningful
Like a boy band.
The boy band formula was basically cognitive science.
Boy bands were more than just musical groups. They were storage devices.
All members had:
Recognizable identity Clear role Clear emotional appeal
there was:
A bad girl, a lover, a mysterious person, an interesting person, a future solo career, a person whose parents trusted them a little more than others (in a group of 5, this often overlaps with the lover)
This wasn’t random. This made it easier to cognitively process and remember the group. Here you will find important learning principles. This means that your memory will improve by making distinctions. When everything feels the same during a workout, your brain compresses it into a beige corporate soup. But learners retain more when elements are differentiated, emotionally resonant, or surprising.
You need ‘Justin Timberlake/Harry Styles’ in your workout
I said what I said. A memorable learning experience requires elements that stand out. It’s not chaos. It’s not a gimmick. A distinctive anchor.
In cognitive psychology, this is tied to the von Restorff effect, the idea that things that are unusual or emotionally different are more likely to be remembered.
translation? Your brain remembers:
Things that are weird, things that are interesting, things that are emotional, things that break the pattern.
Here’s why:
Story works Humor works Scenario works Surprise works
And why doesn’t anyone remember slide 47 of “Q3 Policy Update_Final_FINAL_v2”?
Repetition is key (but not soul-crushing)
Do you know why I still know the lyrics to a song I haven’t heard in 15 years?
you…_________ [you know you know it]
The One…_______ [come on, it’s already in your head]
repetition. But the key is meaningful repetition.
Boy bands have mastered this:
A repeating chorus A repeating theme A repeating emotional message
The brain loves patterns. In science learning, repetition strengthens neural pathways and improves memory. But this is where L&D sometimes goes horribly wrong. We confuse repetition with giving learners the same information 14 times in the same boring way.
It’s not reinforcements, it’s hostage negotiations.
Effective repetition:
Reconsider concepts in different contexts. Facilitate collection. Build your application over time.
This is why scenario-based reinforcement and spaced learning are so powerful in modern training design.
Emotion Is The Real Lead Singer
Here’s something that many organizations overlook. That is, emotions drive memories.
The amygdala helps determine what is stored long-term. This means that learners are more likely to remember experiences associated with:
Humor Curiosity Nervousness Surprise Empathy Pride Even slight embarrassment (with respect)
This explains why it’s remembered:
Ordering someone’s lunch when I was in middle school. Every lyric of the song is tied to an emotional memory. A scary icebreaker when I joined in 2017.
Emotions trigger searches. Dry information alone is rarely effective.
Storytelling is basically a boy band world tour study
No one fell in love with a boy band because of raw data. Persons involved:
Story Personality Drama Identity Relationship
Stories create context. Context creates meaning. Meaning improves memory.
This is why storytelling is one of the most effective teaching tools we have. This is also why the design of powerful learning experiences focuses on creating emotional and cognitive engagement rather than simply providing information.
The brain remembers stories more effectively than disconnected facts.
Organize your information. evoke emotions. Create a sequence. Improve your search.
This means your training should no longer sound like “Please review the following policy framework…”
…and it starts to sound like, “This is a situation you would probably encounter in real life.”
Multisensory learning: Or why we learned dance moves against our will
Boy bands were more than just an auditory experience. they were:
Visual Social Kinesthetic Emotional
There was also a music video. dance moves. fashion. concert. Products (yes, I still have a set of NKOTB bed sheets. I’m not ashamed of it). Magazine interview. fan community.
The more ways the brain engages with information, the stronger the encoding becomes.
That’s why a powerful learning experience combines:
Visual Discussion Practice Reflection Application
Not because it’s trendy, but because it works.
Social learning is criminally underrated
Honestly, half the fun of being in a boy band was arguing with your friends about which members were objectively better. (And yes, people have absolutely ended friendships over this.) But discussing information socially strengthens memory.
Humans learn socially. I always have it. Here’s why:
Discussion Peer Learning Role Play Collaboration Coaching
…often more impactful than passive content consumption.
Learning is more likely to stick when people actively learn together.
The real problem: We design for perfection, not recall.
This is the big one. Most trainings are optimized to:
Scalability Speed Compliance Efficiency
Very few are optimized for memory.
If learners are unable to retrieve and apply the information later, the learning experience has failed, regardless of completion rate.
That’s an inconvenient truth.
So what actually makes training stick?
Strip away the glittery jackets and emotionally aggressive key changes, and memorable learning typically includes:
1. Emotional connection
People remember things that make them feel something.
2. Features
Novelty and surprise improve recall.
3. Repetition over time
Spaced reinforcement trumps information dumping.
4. Storytelling
Context improves encoding and retrieval.
5. Active participation
Thinking trumps passive consumption.
6. Social processing
Discussion increases retention rates.
7. Real-world applications
Use it to strengthen your memory.
In other words, memorable learning is felt to be experienced rather than simply consumed.
I refuse to age myself by revealing which era of boy bands shaped my youth, but here is a picture of me as an adult attending a New Kids on the Block/Backstreet Boys concert. Anyway, it honestly tells you everything you need to know.
Final Thoughts: Become BTS in Training
Well, maybe not literally. Your compliance course probably doesn’t require synchronized choreography. (But to be honest, I’d like to at least hear the pitch.)
However, a memorable workout requires:
Personality Emotional Strengthening Personality Relationships
The brain is not designed to retain general information indefinitely. It’s designed to remember things that feel meaningful.
So the next time you design training, ask yourself, “Will my learners remember this in six months?”
Or will it just disappear into the same void?
Password Reset Email Corporate Mission Statement And all the cybersecurity modules with stock photos of hackers in hoodies?
Because if New Kids on the Block, Backstreet Boys, and BTS can live rent-free in our heads for decades… your workouts can probably be a little better, too.
Image credits: Photos in the article were provided by the author.
Share with
